Bacterial Self-Healing Concrete

This is a new innovation...

The First Case of Self-Healing Concrete...

The first known case of self-healing concrete can be found in Italy, in what was then known as the Roman Empire. Buildings such as the Pantheon and the Colosseum built over 2000 years ago still stand today - a feat that modern day concrete would not be able to do.

The Colosseum in Rome, Italy. The Pantheon in Rome, Italy.

For years, it was a mystery as to why Roman concrete was able to stay standing for so long. Scientists originally thought that it must have been due to pozzolanic material (ie. volcanic ash!) mixed into the concrete before it was set. However, recent research at MIT has proved that this is not the case…

Throughout the lifetime of a concrete structure, hairline fractures and cracks appear in concrete. This can happen for many reasons, but the main cause is the concrete being put in tension. In compression, concrete is very strong, but the smallest bit of tension can cause concrete to fracture! Compared to the lifetime of these ancient buildings, modern day concrete only lasts about 100 years or so. And this is with regular maintenance! So how can these Roman structures still be standing?

The answer lies in the presence of white chunks of material in the mix called ‘lime clasts’. It was originally believed that the presence of these chunks was due to improper mixing of the concrete before setting it. It turns out that these lime clasts were actually giving the concrete a self-healing ability!

A hand holding a chunk of Roman concrete.

When fractures and cracks occurred in the concrete, the lime clasts were activated by the moisture inlet and recrystalise, filling up the cracks with calcium carbonate. The calcium carbonate solution could also react with the pozzolanic materials in the concrete to further strengthen the material. So, whilst Roman concrete is weaker than the Portland mix we use today, it stands the test of time with no issues!

After this discovery, it was clear that the Romans had used a different concrete mixing method than we thought. Initially, it was assumed that the Romans had mixed lime with water to form a paste – a process called slaking. However, this process does not account for the presence of the lime clasts in the concrete. So, it was clear that the Romans must have used a different technique in junction with slaking.

Admir Masic, MIT professor of civil and environmental engineering, wondered whether the Romans had used lime in a more reactive form, known as quicklime. The answer was found after a spectrographic examination of a sample of concrete that proved that the lime clasts had been formed at extreme temperatures. If quicklime was added to the concrete, an exothermic reaction would have occurred, heating up the concrete as it was mixed.

The answer was clear – Romans had hot mixed their concrete.

There are many benefits to hot mixing concrete. One of these benefits being the formation of lime clasts in the concrete, allowing the structures to supersede their builders’ lifetimes. Another benefit is that the setting times of the concrete are radically improved due to the high starting temperature. This means that construction can be completed a lot faster than concrete made with slaking methods.

Unfortunately, it would be incredibly difficult to apply the hot mixing method to the modern world. Using quicklime would mean that concrete would have to be mixed on site due to the faster reaction, which can prove difficult in cramped modern building sites. There are also health risks due to the exothermic reaction involved in making the concrete. Portland cement is also a lot easier to mass produce, which is a necessity in the fast-growing concrete jungles now spreading across the globe.

However, there is a lesson to be learnt in the importance of the durability of the materials we build out of. With cement production currently accounting for about 8% of global greenhouse gas emissions, it is incredibly important that the structures we build last as long as they can to work towards the goal of more sustainable cities.

Image credits

Colosseum found at: https://www.bucketlisttravels.com/experience/the-colosseum

Pantheon found at: https://citywonders.com/blog/Italy/Rome/guide-incredible-history-of-the-pantheon.

Concrete found at: https://www.asme.org/topics-resources/content/ancient-roman-concrete-stands-test-time